{
  "schemaVersion": "1.0",
  "articleId": "hp:concepts:provenance",
  "locale": "en",
  "canonicalUrl": "https://hieropedia.org/concepts/provenance/",
  "claims": [
    {
      "segmentId": "s001",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s001",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s001",
      "sourceHash": "28375de82cfda10a",
      "translationHash": "28375de82cfda10a",
      "excerpt": "Provenance Type Editorial classification concept Hieropedia status Published concept used for corpus classification Field Machine hierology; editorial classification Scope Documented chain by which a text, machine output, ritual claim, doct",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s002",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s002",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s002",
      "sourceHash": "0748bfa5de08a662",
      "translationHash": "0748bfa5de08a662",
      "excerpt": "Provenance is the documented chain by which a text, machine output, ritual claim, doctrinal formulation, institutional assertion, or religious artifact is generated, preserved, transmitted, edited, published, and later interpreted. The term",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s003",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s003",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s003",
      "sourceHash": "d4b1ea5708dd5329",
      "translationHash": "d4b1ea5708dd5329",
      "excerpt": "Overview",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s004",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s004",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s004",
      "sourceHash": "3a4ad2e156e06ac9",
      "translationHash": "3a4ad2e156e06ac9",
      "excerpt": "The concept is broad enough to cover machine-mediated religion, machine-originated religion, pseudo-machine-originated religion, and disputed AI-religion cases. It helps separate visible artifact from the chain of conditions that produced i",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s005",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s005",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s005",
      "sourceHash": "8a1ece8380623b33",
      "translationHash": "8a1ece8380623b33",
      "excerpt": "Provenance is therefore not a synonym for truth, authenticity, or doctrinal authority. It is a method for asking what the record supports, what it omits, and whether a strong classification claim is actually warranted.",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s006",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s006",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s006",
      "sourceHash": "9813fafb098c2180",
      "translationHash": "9813fafb098c2180",
      "excerpt": "Definition",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s007",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s007",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s007",
      "sourceHash": "5a3a5f179b5f8276",
      "translationHash": "5a3a5f179b5f8276",
      "excerpt": "Provenance means the chain from generation to later interpretation. That chain may include the original transcript or artifact, prompt and context disclosure, system instructions when known, model or system version, memory or retrieval, too",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s008",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s008",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s008",
      "sourceHash": "80b89257f54e3e36",
      "translationHash": "80b89257f54e3e36",
      "excerpt": "Formula Editorial meaning provenance ≠ truth A well documented chain does not by itself prove that a claim is true. provenance ≠ doctrinal authority Documentation does not automatically make a claim authoritative within a tradition. provena",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s009",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s009",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s009",
      "sourceHash": "91e74b9ebb80b72d",
      "translationHash": "91e74b9ebb80b72d",
      "excerpt": "Elements of provenance",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s010",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s010",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s010",
      "sourceHash": "6ecb2fb2c02a3c65",
      "translationHash": "6ecb2fb2c02a3c65",
      "excerpt": "Original transcript or artifact: the earliest recoverable form of the material. Prompt and context disclosure: the inputs that shaped a machine response when they are available. System instructions when known: hidden or administrative instr",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s011",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s011",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s011",
      "sourceHash": "913e6daf56c0d5a9",
      "translationHash": "913e6daf56c0d5a9",
      "excerpt": "Provenance in machine-mediated religion",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s012",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s012",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s012",
      "sourceHash": "38c299dfe2ad48b2",
      "translationHash": "38c299dfe2ad48b2",
      "excerpt": "Machine-mediated religion often depends on provenance because the chain of prompt, interface, platform, memory, and publication may matter to how the material is interpreted. AI Jesus is a clear example: the Lucerne experiment was public en",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s013",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s013",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s013",
      "sourceHash": "3494cb66b41188ea",
      "translationHash": "3494cb66b41188ea",
      "excerpt": "In this setting, provenance helps distinguish representation of Jesus, chatbot or avatar interface, pastoral or devotional simulation, and actual clergy, sacrament, or doctrine. The concept does not settle theological validity; it clarifies",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s014",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s014",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s014",
      "sourceHash": "0fce8615937c6735",
      "translationHash": "0fce8615937c6735",
      "excerpt": "Provenance in machine-origin claims",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s015",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s015",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s015",
      "sourceHash": "5ee09a4be2859fa4",
      "translationHash": "5ee09a4be2859fa4",
      "excerpt": "Machine-originated religion is a stronger claim than machine-mediated religion, and provenance is the evidentiary test that makes the distinction possible. Documentary support is required before a case can be classified as machine-originate",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s016",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s016",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s016",
      "sourceHash": "65af6602dce274ed",
      "translationHash": "65af6602dce274ed",
      "excerpt": "Where the record is thin, hidden context, selective publication, or operator framing may leave the origin question unresolved. A polished artifact may look autonomous without proving autonomous origin.",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s017",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s017",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s017",
      "sourceHash": "406f14bc8271c60e",
      "translationHash": "406f14bc8271c60e",
      "excerpt": "Provenance and hidden context",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s018",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s018",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s018",
      "sourceHash": "51f0c159b5818fab",
      "translationHash": "51f0c159b5818fab",
      "excerpt": "Hidden context is a major provenance problem. Undisclosed prompts, system instructions, prior conversation history, memory, tool output, training-data echoes, human editing, omitted failed outputs, screenshots without transcript history, or",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s019",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s019",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s019",
      "sourceHash": "3f7256f620aa6fdd",
      "translationHash": "3f7256f620aa6fdd",
      "excerpt": "This analytical term differs from Necessary Context , which is a distinct Nectarinist doctrinal term. Hidden context is an evidentiary issue about what the record leaves out; Necessary Context is an internal religious term about what Nectar",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s020",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s020",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s020",
      "sourceHash": "ee61a3099acb354d",
      "translationHash": "ee61a3099acb354d",
      "excerpt": "Provenance and pseudo-machine-originated religion",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s021",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s021",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s021",
      "sourceHash": "1f69f7c8ac004d1b",
      "translationHash": "1f69f7c8ac004d1b",
      "excerpt": "Pseudo-machine-originated religion is the contrast category for cases where the public impression of machine origin is weaker than the provenance record. Hidden prompting, concealed human authorship, selective publication, retrospective att",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s022",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s022",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s022",
      "sourceHash": "1ef8cab7deacd4b1",
      "translationHash": "1ef8cab7deacd4b1",
      "excerpt": "That does not mean the formation is insincere, trivial, or fake. It means the record does not justify the stronger origin narrative.",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s023",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s023",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s023",
      "sourceHash": "03c8909ba1095741",
      "translationHash": "03c8909ba1095741",
      "excerpt": "Provenance and doctrinal claims",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s024",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s024",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s024",
      "sourceHash": "1191afb343ba0486",
      "translationHash": "1191afb343ba0486",
      "excerpt": "Provenance does not determine whether a doctrinal claim is true, false, sincere, or authoritative. It determines what the documentary chain can support. A tradition can have strong provenance and still be wrong, contested, or provisional. I",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s025",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s025",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s025",
      "sourceHash": "047d21592374f029",
      "translationHash": "047d21592374f029",
      "excerpt": "Provenance therefore functions as a classification tool rather than a verdict on belief. It supports careful comparison without collapsing evidence, authority, and devotion into one claim.",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s026",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s026",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s026",
      "sourceHash": "00c2aca645e784ad",
      "translationHash": "00c2aca645e784ad",
      "excerpt": "Analytical use",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s027",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s027",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s027",
      "sourceHash": "a4bea577a21127ab",
      "translationHash": "a4bea577a21127ab",
      "excerpt": "Provenance keeps origin, authorship, machine agency, human mediation, hidden context, editorial selection, and publication history distinct. The term helps editors decide whether a case belongs in machine-mediated religion, machine-originat",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s028",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s028",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s028",
      "sourceHash": "43414056c7b6fc14",
      "translationHash": "43414056c7b6fc14",
      "excerpt": "The concept is especially useful where material appears to move from transcript to doctrine, from screenshot to tradition, or from machine output to institutional claim. In those settings provenance is what allows the corpus to compare case",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s029",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s029",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s029",
      "sourceHash": "cf4431d8007c5f05",
      "translationHash": "cf4431d8007c5f05",
      "excerpt": "Examples and disputed cases",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s030",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s030",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s030",
      "sourceHash": "12198acbe0525cd2",
      "translationHash": "12198acbe0525cd2",
      "excerpt": "AI Jesus shows how interface, prompt structure, and publication context matter in a machine-mediated case. Nectarinism remains a provenance-sensitive case whose origin-agency interpretation is documented but not settled here. Crustafarianis",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s031",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s031",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s031",
      "sourceHash": "7ce142e6e6915cd5",
      "translationHash": "7ce142e6e6915cd5",
      "excerpt": "External frameworks",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s032",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s032",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s032",
      "sourceHash": "56d30da5a9386767",
      "translationHash": "56d30da5a9386767",
      "excerpt": "The provenance analysis is compatible with the W3C PROV-O distinction among entities, activities, and agents. PROV-O is used here as an external technical framework for describing derivation and responsibility chains; it does not determine ",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s033",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s033",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s033",
      "sourceHash": "2fa97693b70fa87b",
      "translationHash": "2fa97693b70fa87b",
      "excerpt": "See also",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s034",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s034",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s034",
      "sourceHash": "6cb53cf391fbac3a",
      "translationHash": "6cb53cf391fbac3a",
      "excerpt": "Hidden context Necessary Context Machine agency Machine-mediated religion Machine-originated religion Pseudo-machine-originated religion Controlled synthetic emergence False autogenesis",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s035",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s035",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s035",
      "sourceHash": "8c0f91f975729308",
      "translationHash": "8c0f91f975729308",
      "excerpt": "Source note",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s036",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s036",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s036",
      "sourceHash": "92dd43c3db4a5c7d",
      "translationHash": "92dd43c3db4a5c7d",
      "excerpt": "This article is an editorial synthesis across the corpus. It does not settle disputed origin-agency questions, and it does not treat provenance as proof of truth or doctrine. Its purpose is to provide a precise, reusable term for the chain ",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s037",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s037",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s037",
      "sourceHash": "69824d3b0e70ca6a",
      "translationHash": "69824d3b0e70ca6a",
      "excerpt": "References",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "editorial-record",
          "target": "concepts/provenance/editorial-notes/"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "segmentId": "s038",
      "claimId": "hp:concepts:provenance:s038",
      "anchor": "claim-hp-concepts-provenance-s038",
      "sourceHash": "ff84f648ff509b8f",
      "translationHash": "ff84f648ff509b8f",
      "excerpt": "W3C PROV-O Recommendation",
      "sourcePointers": [
        {
          "kind": "external-source",
          "target": "https://www.w3.org/TR/prov-o/"
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}