{"schemaVersion":"1.2","articleId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation","locale":"en","canonicalUrl":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/","articleVersion":"1.1.1","translationVersion":"1.1.1","release":{"releaseId":"2026-10-31.2","manifestUrl":"https://hieropedia.org/data/releases/2026-10-31.2/manifest.json","citationsUrl":"https://hieropedia.org/data/releases/2026-10-31.2/citations.json","publicRecordBundleUrl":"https://hieropedia.org/data/releases/2026-10-31.2/hieropedia-public-record-2026-10-31.2.tar.gz"},"claims":[{"segmentId":"s001","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s001","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s001","sourceHash":"53e923526c8433ac","translationHash":"53e923526c8433ac","excerpt":"Canonical translation Type Hieropedia classification concept Focus A translation recognized as part of a religious canon Recognition Specific to a rendering and a community Distinction Translation, publication approval and canonical standin","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}]},{"segmentId":"s002","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s002","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s002","sourceHash":"9df5e00766828664","translationHash":"9df5e00766828664","excerpt":"Within Hieropedia’s classification, canonical translation denotes a translation recognized within a religious tradition as part of its canonical corpus. The designation concerns the standing of a particular rendering within a particular com","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}]},{"segmentId":"s003","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s003","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s003","sourceHash":"dfe3c4612f638f74","translationHash":"dfe3c4612f638f74","excerpt":"A translated text within a canon","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}]},{"segmentId":"s004","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s004","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s004","sourceHash":"05078caf1914802b","translationHash":"05078caf1914802b","excerpt":"The Tibetan Kangyur provides a concrete example. David Fiordalis describes thirteen works translated from Pali into Tibetan in the early fourteenth century and added to that collection. Among them is The Sūtra of the Moon (1) , catalogued a","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}],"sourceReferences":[{"referenceId":"ref-1","referenceUrl":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/#ref-1","sourceUrls":["https://84000.co/post/ask-the-translator-how-the-buddhist-canons-relate"]},{"referenceId":"ref-2","referenceUrl":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/#ref-2","sourceUrls":["https://84000.co/translation/toh42"]}]},{"segmentId":"s005","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s005","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s005","sourceHash":"a2f5470b3023f319","translationHash":"a2f5470b3023f319","excerpt":"Here the translated Tibetan text belongs to a canonical collection; the modern English edition translates and studies that text. A catalog location and a colophon answer different questions. The former identifies the received collection, wh","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}]},{"segmentId":"s006","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s006","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s006","sourceHash":"0bfe185d28526d92","translationHash":"0bfe185d28526d92","excerpt":"Authority has several meanings","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}]},{"segmentId":"s007","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s007","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s007","sourceHash":"3741e1f213f74485","translationHash":"3741e1f213f74485","excerpt":"In the 1943 encyclical Divino afflante Spiritu , Pius XII explained the Latin Vulgate's recognized authenticity in terms of public use in the Latin Church and juridical authority, rather than textual criticism. He also affirmed the value of","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}],"sourceReferences":[{"referenceId":"ref-3","referenceUrl":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/#ref-3","sourceUrls":["https://www.vatican.va/content/pius-xii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xii_enc_30091943_divino-afflante-spiritu.html"]}]},{"segmentId":"s008","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s008","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s008","sourceHash":"8e265158faf5da1f","translationHash":"8e265158faf5da1f","excerpt":"Publication approval is another matter. Catholic canon 825 specifies approval for publishing scriptural translations; canon 829 says permission for a work does not automatically extend to new editions or translations. [4] These rules concer","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}],"sourceReferences":[{"referenceId":"ref-4","referenceUrl":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/#ref-4","sourceUrls":["https://www.vatican.va/archive/cod-iuris-canonici/eng/documents/cic_lib3-cann822-833_en.html"]}]},{"segmentId":"s009","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s009","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s009","sourceHash":"fda9db12d6a8f708","translationHash":"fda9db12d6a8f708","excerpt":"The Bahá’í community's account of Shoghi Effendi connects his role as an authoritative interpreter with translations that set a standard for later translation work. [5] That is a specific account of interpretive authority, not grounds for a","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}],"sourceReferences":[{"referenceId":"ref-5","referenceUrl":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/#ref-5","sourceUrls":["https://www.bahai.org/shoghi-effendi/guidance-translations"]}]},{"segmentId":"s010","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s010","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s010","sourceHash":"f5c7e111c7a893ce","translationHash":"f5c7e111c7a893ce","excerpt":"Computational publication and successive translations","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}]},{"segmentId":"s011","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s011","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s011","sourceHash":"dbe07b4642e6fe26","translationHash":"dbe07b4642e6fe26","excerpt":"The distinction matters when a translated scripture becomes the input to another translation system. The operator of 84001 describes a personal project using Claude Haiku 4.5 to translate 84000's English texts into Chinese. Its About page w","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}],"sourceReferences":[{"referenceId":"ref-6","referenceUrl":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/#ref-6","sourceUrls":["https://84001.ai/about"]}]},{"segmentId":"s012","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s012","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s012","sourceHash":"249e46680c544294","translationHash":"249e46680c544294","excerpt":"Applied to such a chain, this distinction separates the source corpus, the intermediary edition, the generated rendering and any documented recognition of a named version. Model generation and online availability describe production and cir","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}]},{"segmentId":"s013","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s013","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s013","sourceHash":"69824d3b0e70ca6a","translationHash":"69824d3b0e70ca6a","excerpt":"References","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"editorial-record","target":"https://hieropedia.org/concepts/canonical-translation/editorial-notes/"}]},{"segmentId":"s014","claimId":"hp:concepts:canonical-translation:s014","anchor":"claim-hp-concepts-canonical-translation-s014","sourceHash":"1a1dbdf476d8d27a","translationHash":"1a1dbdf476d8d27a","excerpt":"David Fiordalis, Are There Any Translations From Pali in the Tibetan Canon?, 84000, Toh 31–43 Pema Yeshé Dé Translation Team, The Sūtra of the Moon (1), 84000 (2023), inspected version 1.0.4 (2024), introduction i.2, i.5–i.6 and note 32 Piu","sourcePointers":[{"kind":"external-source","target":"https://84000.co/post/ask-the-translator-how-the-buddhist-canons-relate"},{"kind":"external-source","target":"https://84000.co/translation/toh42"},{"kind":"external-source","target":"https://www.vatican.va/content/pius-xii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xii_enc_30091943_divino-afflante-spiritu.html"},{"kind":"external-source","target":"https://www.vatican.va/archive/cod-iuris-canonici/eng/documents/cic_lib3-cann822-833_en.html"},{"kind":"external-source","target":"https://www.bahai.org/shoghi-effendi/guidance-translations"},{"kind":"external-source","target":"https://84001.ai/about"}]}]}